Indonesia is home to over 17,000 islands, yet only a handful offer what true private island luxury promises: complete seclusion, immersive nature, and a sense that you’ve stepped entirely off the map.

These are not the glossy, overbuilt resorts you’ll find elsewhere in Southeast Asia. Instead, Indonesia’s most exclusive island stays feel wilder, more remote, and deeply connected to their surroundings – where jungle meets reef, and barefoot luxury still feels authentic.

Having experienced some of the country’s most remarkable escapes firsthand – and researched others widely regarded as among the best in the world – these are the private island resorts in Indonesia that stand apart.

Amanwana: A remote island sanctuary with Aman’s signature restraint

Tucked away on the protected island of Moyo, Amanwana feels less like a resort and more like a well-kept secret.

There are no overwater villas here, no infinity pools competing for attention. Instead, guests stay in safari-style tents set along the shoreline, designed to blend seamlessly into the landscape. It’s understated, intentional, and entirely in line with the Aman philosophy.

Days unfold slowly – snorkelling untouched reefs, hiking to hidden waterfalls like Diana Falls, or simply watching the tide shift from your deck. Wildlife is part of the experience too, with monkeys and deer often passing through the grounds.

This is private island living in its purest form: quiet, immersive, and deeply restorative.

Best for: Aman loyalists, couples, and families seeking true off-grid luxury.

→ Read my full Amanwana review here.

Bawah Reserve: Barefoot luxury, redefined

If Amanwana is understated, Bawah Reserve is quietly spectacular.

Accessible only by private seaplane, this collection of six islands in the Anambas archipelago feels impossibly remote. The lagoon alone – a swirling palette of blues – is enough to justify the journey.

Villas are spread across beaches, overwater decks, and jungle hillsides, each designed with sustainability at its core. There’s a strong sense of place here, from the architecture to the dining, which focuses on fresh, locally inspired cuisine.

Despite its exclusivity, Bawah feels warm rather than formal. It’s the kind of place where shoes are forgotten quickly, and days revolve around the ocean.

Best for: Honeymoons, special occasions, and those wanting luxury without formality.

→ Read my full Bawah Reserve review here.

NIHI Sumba: Wild, untamed, and unlike anywhere else

While I haven’t personally stayed at NIHI Sumba yet, it is consistently ranked among the best resorts in the world – and for good reason.

Set on the remote island of Sumba, NIHI is raw, expansive, and deeply connected to local culture. Villas are scattered across a rugged coastline, each with sweeping ocean views and complete privacy.

Experiences here are what set it apart: horseback riding along empty beaches at sunset, surfing the legendary Occy’s Left, or visiting nearby villages as part of the resort’s community foundation.

It’s not polished in the way some luxury resorts are – and that’s exactly the point – and firmly on my list for a future visit.

Best for: Adventurous travellers, surfers, and those seeking something truly different.

Why choose a private island in Indonesia?

Unlike destinations like the Maldives, where private island resorts are more standardised, Indonesia offers something far more diverse.

Each island has its own identity – shaped by landscape, culture, and remoteness. From the jungle-covered wilderness of Moyo to the turquoise lagoons of Bawah and the rugged coastline of Sumba, no two experiences feel the same.

For travellers willing to go a little further, the reward is a kind of luxury that feels rarer: quieter, less commercial, and more personal.

Planning your stay

Getting to these islands is part of the adventure — and often part of their appeal.

• Amanwana is typically accessed via Bali, followed by a short flight and boat transfer
• Bawah Reserve requires a private seaplane from Batam via a ferry from Singapore
• NIHI Sumba is reached via a domestic flight from Bali

If you’re deciding between destinations or looking to plan a multi-stop itinerary through Indonesia, I now offer a bespoke travel planning service tailored to your style of travel.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best private island resort in Indonesia?
It depends on your travel style. Amanwana offers understated, nature-led luxury, Bawah Reserve is ideal for barefoot indulgence, while NIHI Sumba is best for adventure and cultural immersion.

Are private island resorts in Indonesia family-friendly?
Yes – though it varies significantly by property.

• Amanwana is particularly well suited to families with young children, including babies. During our stay, Ryder (aged 3) was warmly included in activities, and complimentary babysitting is offered for up to four hours per day, with additional hours available at USD $20 per hour. The team are incredibly accommodating, making it one of the more flexible private island options for families travelling with younger kids.
• Bawah Reserve welcomes children aged five and above, though due to the intimate size of the resort it is generally better suited to older children and couples. Suites are designed for two guests, with the option to add one additional bed for an extra cost.
• NIHI Sumba welcomes families of all ages and offers a range of experiences across the property. For children aged 5–12, the complimentary Wildlings program provides a structured, full-day experience with outdoor adventures, cultural activities, and creative workshops. Given its expansive and adventurous setting, it is often best suited to slightly older children.

How do you get to private island resorts in Indonesia?
Most require a combination of flights and boat or seaplane transfers, typically routed via Bali or Batam.